Divorce, depression, and self-reflectivity. These are the themes that have been haunting Hayes Carll’s previous albums up until recently. What It Is breaks out of that shell and embraces the ability for change and well-balanced wittiness, to shine through in his lyrics and the overall theme of the album; integrating personal and political into his tracklist.
Hayes Carll’s album uses all of the conventional country elements-fiddles and guitars included- as well as his Texan and Nashville roots, to create a fun, and meaningful outlook on how he sees his life through a new rose-coloured lens. The album is light and simple with underlying political tones that reflect all that Hayes has learned and observed over the past year, he hides under the familiar dry humour that features in his other albums, and allows the listeners to slow down and meditate on the ideas he poses about how we see the world around us. In an interview with Rolling Stones Country, Carll explains his inspiration for writing the album and why.
“I take stock of the world around me and write about it […] This isn’t by any means a political record, but there are observations or my takes on certain things that are important. I understand a lot of people look to music as an escape, it can be really upsetting when it feels like that’s disrupted.”
Hayes Carll on his sixth album.
His first song on the album titled “None’ya” is an homage to his country background and a testimony to his wife, in which the album is co-written by her. It is one of his many love songs on the album that is self-reflecting without much reflecting going on, Carll’s witty lyrics prevent the listeners to delve anywhere deeper than the initial surface level. I find that splashing around on the surface, eases the listener into the political undertones of his music. His chorus hits home on the thought of changing aspects of his own life, “I try because I want to/ I know you heart the best way that I can/ Girl all I want to do is be your man.” It’s also interesting to listen to the love songs on the album and notice that he is singing in a first-person perspective that proves in his lines that he is singing and reflecting on himself and the idea of masculinity- how he can be a better man and husband, not just the fact that his woman in question is both cool and eccentric.
The lines in his second track, “Times Like These” mask the social and political messages behind upbeat fiddle chords and melodic singing, with lyrics such as, “but it sure is getting warm ‘round here in times like these/ in times like these do I really need a billionaire?” Carll delivers the balance between music and lyrics in sort of a “late-night barstool nightclub performance scene” that is personal and eye-opening if you listen to the lyrics close enough. The order of the tracklist is delicately balanced between slow and fast-tempoed songs, for the most part, equally alternating between what I like to refer to as “the fine line between falling back in love, and falling out of love with the world”. The variety of tracks mixed with the fussy string and brass arrangements, bring an unwavering directness to the character’s narrative, that Carll creates with telling this narrative as he’s sitting on a stool and an open-mic bar in a small town.
About nearly halfway into the album, something that Carll, Allison Moore, and the producers do significantly, is create an equilibrium between soft-strumming guitar and wailing harmonicas with the almost rock n’ roll style drumming and guitar chords. In songs, like “Things You Don’t Wanna Know” and “If I May Be So Bold” are the love songs that slow down the album’s movement altogether, and give profound and thoughtful lyrics to lead the audience towards the first central idea that he discovered when writing this album. He wrote it as a way to reflect on himself and the person he is today because of his tumultuous past. “I’ve wrestled with the question of just who I aim to be/ Been dealt hands I had to laugh at/ And some hands I’d like to fold/ But I’ll play ’em all, if I may be so bold…” lyrics like these show just how much he has grown since his last album, Lovers and Leavers, rising from the ashes of heartbreak and divorce to the next stage of turning over a new leaf with a new wife and a new life as a better man. The last couple of tracks on the album refer to the political approach he’s trying to shed light on in the matter. “The whole world is exploding and I know it feels so strange/ It must make you so damn angry they’re expecting you to change/ Fragile men” In this song, he calls out the right wing Americans who refuse to change their political views to match the evolving state of the world we are living in today.
Overall, the message of the album is widely pleasing to listen to because its melodic and upbeat nature of the tracks. The instruments and sentimental lyrics play together beautifully to present a simple and light-hearted sound that you can listen to anytime. However, if you wanted to listen more intuitively to the album and its underlying meaning, you are able to hear the message of the song jumping out subtly at you- its hidden under classic country chords and dry-humoured wit. The album is great to listen to if you just need a simple soundtrack to listen to on your teal-painted front porch on a sunny afternoon in the South.
-Genna Dara







